Oh, thanks!

It's super strange.
.ods one not opens and asks password, .xlsx one have points from screenshot attached.

[attachment deleted by admin]

According to changelog mediocore commanders got price reduction, but at this one drive builder shows old costs.

https://onedrive.live.com/?authkey=%21AMlBVUnRFKNtfK4&id=DFF15D0B1FF429B0%2151315&cid=DFF15D0B1FF429B0

Am I looking at wrong place?

Thank you for answer

Quote from: lionheartrjc on September 18, 2024, 08:33:32 AM
Troops that counter-charged or intercepted may not shoot (see clarifications).

I can't find it in clarification on website, it was lost during updates or I'm just can't find it, can you point me to page/bullet?

Quote from: lionheartrjc on September 18, 2024, 08:33:32 AM
Follow the turn sequence (1:C page 24).

Turn sequence tells me nothing about who can shoot, if I'm reading properly and not missed obvious bullet.


Other points are clear, thanks.

Hi!
As my friend explore rulebook with fresh eye we found this question.
If someones charge path lies in 1 BW forward of other charging/intercepting/countercharging unit - can that unit shoot?
I'm completely sure that can't, but struggle with finding clarification. Shooting section of rulebook says that chargers can't shoot in shooting phase, but for charging phase it forwards to charging section and M1 says only

QuoteFiles can shoot at chargers if the path of charge passes within 1BW and ahead of them, as shown in the example below. This is defined before shooting as the UGs being charged have already declared their responses. Shooters can also fire at enemy countercharging or intercepting that have come within 1BW

Hi!
How allied contingents work in this list?
Can I take both?
French is just 1 commander and 1 unit?

Thanks for answer.

What's the difference between 1 and 2? Why DC is +0 vs EL works and exception on SSp not used?
Because DC have straight value and SSp has "except"?

By the way, it looks like DC in elephant's flank is +3 because of general claim "Cv, Cm, Ch, or El vs. foot not standing to receive", right?

Hi!

1) My Devastating chargers contacted Elephant in the rear, did I have +claim for DC? or rear of elephant is still elephant? Can I use shatter?
2) Same, my mounted short spears charges flank of pikemen, is it +1 or +0?
3) My Devastating chargers received rear charge, can they achieve shatter?

Ok, so it's more question about game design.
What dictated measuring from generals when whey attached?
As I think - it's really simplifies positioning and I'm not seeing super opportunity in sitting inside big footprint file.

1. It was about case with no room for general.
2. So, in this case, all distances will be measured from file?

Hi!
We are always played as you measure range from file, which general is attached. But after searching on forum I see what range measured from actual location of general.
So, because I see no chapter in rules about measuring command range - I have question:
If, because point 11.2, general is removed from table - from where you measure command range?
And, in same point - if only room for general is flank of file - can it be placed here?

Hi!
As I see - in 2023 list:
Veteran Punic cavalry with melee expert should cost 172, but builder shows to me 173
which one points is right?

Thank you!

Hi!
How you are modeled 2h cut and crush optional legionaries?
Which weapon they are supposed to carry?

Thanks!

Thank you.
And if receiving charge unit align attacker A, attacker B will not have space for charge?
Or can charge in corner contact?

And one more question about charge phase. If pursuing unit contact existing melee - it will join that fight, right?
But that happens if that melee already resolved? Rules states that if pursuing unit contacts enemy in charge phase - melee is resolved in that phase.

Hi!
More stupid question from me:
I'm playing pacto and units A and B declares charge on unit C.
Is it possible to end charge move as shown?
Is one of units A and B will fight as supporting file or I should calculate dice colour separately A and B will roll their resulting dice and C will roll dice once, against chosen enemy?



Thank you!