Ally from List 2717 later Moorish

Started by philfigo, March 19, 2024, 11:02:26 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

philfigo

If this list is taken as an ally how do we manage the nobles?

"Nobles must be in the Army Commander's command."

Can we take them?
Under what command?

Princeps

Section 2.D.1 of rules (PDF p. 32) states that : Sub-generals can be allies with a dedicated command - the number and type of allies allowed for each army are shown in our army lists..

This has to be combined with the rule (non-contradictory, fortunately) at the beginning of each army book : [...]Unless specified in the notes, the general must be the same type as the army commander in their own army's list but cannot be legendary. Usually this results in 1-3 UGs being compulsory and you having full flexibility on the rest. [...]

My read is that : the general commanding the ally, although with the same type as the Army Commander, is not an AC, but a Sub-General. Therefore he cannot command a unit reserved for AC.

Best,
Antoine

Onurbm


My read same , Nobles , if taken must be in the army commander command ( c-c ) .
An yes I take them all for next weekend  in Chaniers
Bruno
La question n'est pas de savoir si nous aurons le temps mais bien , ce que nous allons faire avec le temps qui nous est imparti .
GANDALF

philfigo

Ok, I could only use it in a private game where the Moorish allied king comes with his nobles

Thank you

badhabum

By the way just for infos as I had a discussion about that specific list the allied byzantine general may be instinctive  8) a minor point but a few points