Question about Ambushes

Started by Agoz, May 07, 2021, 09:50:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Agoz

So for Ambushes, my impression is you place the ambush card in vision blocking terrain and place a note under it stating what it contains, if anything. My question is, isn't my opponent going to know what the Ambushes contain by what I haven't placed on the table? Or is the assumption that they haven't seen my army list?

Jilu

Quote from: Agoz on May 07, 2021, 09:50:51 PM
So for Ambushes, my impression is you place the ambush card in vision blocking terrain and place a note under it stating what it contains, if anything. My question is, isn't my opponent going to know what the Ambushes contain by what I haven't placed on the table? Or is the assumption that they haven't seen my army list?

well yes
but then, lots of units in your list are non compulsory.
or suprises can be fun a 4 base catafract in a forset is always surprising
Liberate me ex infernis

Agoz

Quote from: Jilu on May 08, 2021, 12:30:35 AM
Quote from: Agoz on May 07, 2021, 09:50:51 PM
So for Ambushes, my impression is you place the ambush card in vision blocking terrain and place a note under it stating what it contains, if anything. My question is, isn't my opponent going to know what the Ambushes contain by what I haven't placed on the table? Or is the assumption that they haven't seen my army list?

well yes
but then, lots of units in your list are non compulsory.
or suprises can be fun a 4 base catafract in a forset is always surprising
Sorry, I didn't mean the overall army list from the website, I meant my excel spreadsheet, they should know exactly which units I brought if they've looked at my spreadsheet(Which I bring to my games to prove my list is legal). At the end of deployment it should be a pretty simple matter of looking at the table, seeing what I've placed, and then looking at my spreadsheet, and seeing what I haven't placed out of what I brought to figure out what's in ambush. Which is why I'm asking, do other players hide their army lists from their opponents? Is that what is expected?

nikgaukroger

Showing your opponent your list after deployment is not normal.
"The Roman Empire was not murdered and nor did it die a natural death; it accidentally committed suicide."

Agoz

I see, okay, that would have been considered cheating in other games I've played so that is good to know! Second question, the rules say that up to three ambushes may be placed, but it doesn't say PER PLAYER, meaning that as I understand it the two players have to share the ambush cards. Lets say I'm playing on a particularly terrain dense board and both players want to place as many ambushes as possible, how do I determine who gets access to the ambush cards if both players want all three?

daveparish

There is nothing to stop you showing each other your lists if that is the local convention where you play. If there are ambushes or flank marches just wait until they have been revealed before exchanging lists. Sometimes it can be good to have a check that you haven't accidentally written an illegal list (it has even happened that competition list checkers have let illegal lists through - so it is not always easy to get right!).

badhabum

By the way may an ambush be used to deploy TUGs on the extreme part of an unprotected flank where normaly you may only deploy SUGs ..I did not find a clear answer to this

nikgaukroger

Page 69 Deployment Zones - nice and explicit.
"The Roman Empire was not murdered and nor did it die a natural death; it accidentally committed suicide."

badhabum

 ambushes have special rules very specific and just say you may deploy CLOSER but closer to what ?

And Ok found pg 69

Agoz

Funnily enough I did play a game today where both players wanted all three ambush cards (the game ended up being in dense mountains with a secure flank, nobody placed any open terrain, Classical Greeks ended up winning which is shocking) We just ended up rolling off to determine who got two ambushes and who got one, but I'd like a more official answer as to how the three cards get divvied up.

nikgaukroger

You don't share the ambush cards, only the colour cards. From the glossary entry on Ambushes - "Each player may place up to three of these".
"The Roman Empire was not murdered and nor did it die a natural death; it accidentally committed suicide."

badhabum

yep and pay attention to the "own half of the table" which is more than your deployment zone !

Agoz

Thanks guys, I didn't think to look at the glossary, I assumed the full version of the rule would have been in actual ambush rules.