pre- and Trastámara Spanish

Started by Jilu, December 27, 2021, 04:41:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Jilu

For the landsknechts ;
**Instead of skirmishers

There are no Landknecht skirmishers in the lists
Liberate me ex infernis

lionheartrjc


Jilu

Quote from: lionheartrjc on December 28, 2021, 08:05:38 AM
True.  Perhaps there should be...

seems to be the same in other lists too
Liberate me ex infernis

badhabum

Pre-Cordoba : there are 18 SK handgunners . Perhaps the intention is to include the landsknecht SK
Trastamara : the same

So there are fireweapon SK they could easely also be landsknecht  :)

Jilu

Hello i was wondering if the colunela should not have the KIEL option.

When i read  the formation in REG, this formation has no flank.

Liberate me ex infernis

badhabum

Quote from: Jilu on July 13, 2022, 12:41:45 PM
Hello i was wondering if the colunela should not have the KIEL option.

When i read  the formation in REG, this formation has no flank.

REG is REG , MEG is MEG  ;D

Jilu

Yes and no,.

I fail to see a difference in army lists of the same period why would there be a difference  if both rulesets overlap ?
Liberate me ex infernis

lionheartrjc

MeG was not designed to be extended into the Renaissance period, it also has different people (with different opinions) involved.  Army list design is not a science.

My view of a colunela is that it does not justify the Kiel characteristic.

Richard