How many TuGs are usual at 10K

Started by AntiokosIII, February 04, 2019, 06:18:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

AntiokosIII

I noticed that the last 5-6 lists I have done at 10K all seem to have 9 TuGs and 3-5 Sugs. Most of the armies I see on Saturdays at our game club are similar. Oh, you sometimes see 11 TuGs, and one player this past week has 9 TuGs and 8 SuGs, for a total of 17 deployables.

Are these sizes more or less the same as one sees elsewhere? Larger? Smaller?

Personally, I tend to run a Talented CiC and 2-3 Competent subs with Professionals, or better command with Instinctive. Some people run a Talented Pro and 3 mediocre Pro subs. These choices tend to dictate army size a bit, but I am too cowardly to run all Competents, much less a mix of Competent and mediocre.
DO others agree?
Miniature Wargaming is the only completely honorable form of warfare ever invented by man.

nikgaukroger

In the UK 9 TUGs seems to be seen as the usual minimum for most, although there are exceptions. 11 TUGs seems to me to be popular. SUGs are not that common with quite a few armies having none or the odd one or two - again, inevitable exceptions.
"The Roman Empire was not murdered and nor did it die a natural death; it accidentally committed suicide."

AntiokosIII

Thanks, Nic. I run more Sugs than I consider ideal because I like non-shooty elephants, which really need a screen of infantry skirmishers unsee one is willing to see small units shot to bits before they can stomp the enemy into a bloody pulp.

I also just can't resist whatever skilled shooty light horse is on offer. You get the scouting benny AND useful shooting.
Miniature Wargaming is the only completely honorable form of warfare ever invented by man.

lionheartrjc

I ran a 13 TuG army at Brighton,  but this was Tribal and included 2 TuGs of 4 cavalry.

I did run a 3 TuG Parthian army at Brighton the year before.  This takes a lot of confidence, essentially a lot of horse archers with a few cataphracts.

Most armies are between 9 and 11 TuGs.  This is about right for a 6'x4' (180cm x 120cm) table.

rayfredjohn

I like 13 TuGs because I can swap TuGs with most armies and get a result.

Jason has developed his Mac & Cheese to be 4 TuGs and a load of SuGs.

craig.w

#5
Quote from: rayfredjohn on February 05, 2019, 09:55:10 AM
I like 13 TuGs because I can swap TuGs with most armies and get a result.

Jason has developed his Mac & Cheese to be 4 TuGs and a load of SuGs.

13 TUGs!! Which armies are these? I used Pecheneg in one comp with 5 TUGs, 3 of them wagons, and 8 SUGs, Graeco-Bactrian with 9 TUGs (I had 7 x 6 strong cavalry TUGs) and 2 SUGs, and Post Mongol Russian with 9 TUGs and 1 SUG.

Most of my average cavalry TUGs I run 6 strong, maybe I'm doing something wrong... I'm considering running a full-fat, all skilled, all superior and exceptional Mongol Conquest with 7 TUGs, 0 SUGs in the next comp just to see how bad it is.

rayfredjohn

Quote from: craig.w on February 05, 2019, 12:17:00 PM
Quote from: rayfredjohn on February 05, 2019, 09:55:10 AM
I like 13 TuGs because I can swap TuGs with most armies and get a result.

Jason has developed his Mac & Cheese to be 4 TuGs and a load of SuGs.

13 TUGs!! Which armies are these? I used Pecheneg in one comp with 5 TUGs, 3 of them wagons, and 8 SUGs, Graeco-Bactrian with 9 TUGs (I had 7 x 6 strong cavalry TUGs) and 2 SUGs, and Post Mongol Russian with 9 TUGs and 1 SUG.

Most of my average cavalry TUGs I run 6 strong, maybe I'm doing something wrong... I'm considering running a full-fat, all skilled, all superior and exceptional Mongol Conquest with 7 TUGs, 0 SUGs in the next comp just to see how bad it is.

I think one of the lists this weekend has 20 TuGs and 5 SuGs

nikgaukroger

Quote from: craig.w on February 05, 2019, 12:17:00 PM
13 TUGs!! Which armies are these?

Ones with cheaper troops  ;D

Greuthungi were one of them for example - 4 units warband types and 9 cavalry units a mix of 6's and 4's but mainly 6's.


QuoteGraeco-Bactrian with 9 TUGs (I had 7 x 6 strong cavalry TUGs) and 2 SUGs,

I had 11 TUGS in my 10k Graeco Bactrian - OK 3 were filler Indian bowmen but the other 8 were 6 base cavalry units.
"The Roman Empire was not murdered and nor did it die a natural death; it accidentally committed suicide."

AntiokosIII

@ Mr. Gaukroger- Sir, do you claim to have run Graeco- Bactrians with zero pikes and <shudder> zero elephants? HERESY!!! Which is fine, but why?  Personally, I find pachyderms hard to resist.
Miniature Wargaming is the only completely honorable form of warfare ever invented by man.

nikgaukroger

Haven't got the infantry and nellies in a cavalry army can, in my expereince, be a bit vulnerable so I gave them a miss this time.

This was my list FWIW

"The Roman Empire was not murdered and nor did it die a natural death; it accidentally committed suicide."

Simon Meg-Meister

9/11 the hot spot.

22 for Ikko Ikki!!!
5 for my Parthians

Si
Rolling Skulls in the land or Purple