Hello,
Had this come up in a game. Two cavalry TUGs, slightly past each other's front edges, so both can potentially claim a flank charge.
Both declare a charge (the gauls on the left are forced because they have the enemy 1BW directly in front, the romans are prompted).
Romans are active first, so the Roman player activates, wheels, and makes contact with the gallic flank, causing a flank charge and much unhappiness.
Was there a way for the Gauls to react in time? Countercharge doesn't apply because they are within 1BW of the enemy.
From my reading of the rules, there is no way to counter this. The active player can move the their unit first and hit a flank. It feels a bit.. wrong.
Thanks!
[attachment deleted by admin]
The Gauls needed to react the turn before. They needed to ensure they didn't end up in a position where the Romans can get the flank charge in the following turn.
This is where understanding who will be the active player next turn is important and don't leave your flanks open. It is a significant part of the gamer.
Note: If there are two such situations, at the same point in the game, because of the alternating turn sequence, the Romans would get to charge one then the Gauls would get to charge the next one.
Second note: The Gauls probably also have the option of running away although this may result in them being caught in the rear.
Richard
Quote from: lionheartrjc on April 06, 2021, 07:43:05 AM
Second note: The Gauls probably also have the option of running away although this may result in them being caught in the rear.
Of course they could choose to Skirmish/Run away to their front which may well be a lot safer in this case 8)
The top right TuG cannot declare a flank charge as it does not have any bases fully behind opponents flank
Kokor Hekkus is right
Thanks for all the answers!
@Kokor Hekkus you are totally right. I didn't notice that during the game, but clearly the Roman cav is not quite far enough to be on the flank of the Gauls.
@nikgaukroger, @lionhartrjc ah yes, that is one of those things that just takes time to learn when picking up a new system. I assumed that only SUGs can skirmish / run away and missed that missile armed cav can also do that. Good to know!
And yea, I figured that it comes down to paying attention to player order and avoiding situations like this.